Version imprimable du sujet
Cliquez ici pour voir ce sujet dans son format original
HongKong Cinemagic Forum > Hong Kong Films > Red Cliff 1 & 2, John Woo, 2008


Ecrit par: pieter53 Mardi 28 Avril 2009 15h01
I just had a look at the http://www.hkcinemagic.com/en/info.asp?data=hk-award and I must say that in my opinion Red Cliff is much overrated, but perhaps I'm spoiled after watching the CCTV-series http://www.hkcinemagic.com/en/movie.asp?id=9941.
Those who have read the book, or have watched the series, will be disappointed if they watch Red Cliff. It's not a bad movie, but it doesn't do the magnificent story any justice. A lot of nice things from the book and series are left out and what's left is just a normal movie as so many others, except for the firescenes at the actual battle: they are great, but not any better then those in the series and the same goes for the costumes and sets.

I noticed that the torture of general Huang is mentioned in the movie, but doesn't take place! Probably they left out the complete scene!

Ecrit par: ah_thomas Mardi 28 Avril 2009 16h02
From what I gathered they had to leave a lot of things out. Impossible to mention everything.

What's more, Woo based his film on the actual historical events not the 14th century novel and also developped some characters like Zhou Yu's wife or Princess Sun so as to make sub plots more attractive to any viewers, Chinese, foreigners and those who don't know anything of the Chinese history.

I think the intention wasn't to paste the book on the film. smile.gif
But to show how Chinese are smart and refined. I really liked the battle of wits in the film. As much as the battle with weapons. Plus Woo shows that Chinese are close to nature, animals, have huge talents for arts, etc... icon13.gif

Is the film released in Holland yet, Pieter?

Ecrit par: pieter53 Mardi 28 Avril 2009 16h52
QUOTE
the battle of wits

Which battle of wits? Compared with the TV-series there isn't any!
The characters of Zhuge KongMing (ZhuGe Liang), Lu Su and Chou Yu in the series are great!

As far as I know the 14th century novel is also based on historical facts, more then John Woo's movie I would say. (Females didn't count in those days biggrin.gif whistle.gif )

I've watched the series 3 times, my wife 5 or even more times.
I don't think we will watch Red Cliff a second time!
(As you may understand; we are not John Woo fans blush.gif )



Ecrit par: ah_thomas Mercredi 29 Avril 2009 13h54
I think you are totally right.
The novel is probably 10 times better than the Tv series, itself better than the movie. But with more than 80 episodes, they have time to develop and an edge on the film.

Personnaly I like John Woo and Tony Leung, so a movie with them two is what I have been waiting for for some time now. banana.gif

Ecrit par: pieter53 Mercredi 29 Avril 2009 15h01
QUOTE
Personnaly I like John Woo and Tony Leung, so a movie with them two is what I have been waiting for for some time now.

Personnaly I don't see anything special in the works of Tony Leung and John Woo blink.gif

By the way: I think Generation Pendragon (both films! are also based on ROTK) are more entertaining then Red Cliff, but if you like Red Cliff then it's a good thing the movies are made, isn't it. biggrin.gif

Ecrit par: manolo Jeudi 30 Avril 2009 11h51
I didn't like the movie neither. icon4.gif But thanks to it's release, the novel is re-issued in France. icon13.gif I'll take the chance to get it while it's available at a reasonable price because I can't afford La Pleiade's copy. blush.gif

If I enjoy the book, maybe then I'll look for the TV-serie.

Ecrit par: pieter53 Jeudi 30 Avril 2009 13h30
If you're English is good enough you can download or read the book http://threekingdoms.com/book.aspx, but the translation isn't as good as the one of http://forum.hkcinemagic.com/index.php?showtopic=7635&view=findpost&p=82609 and ofcourse that isn't as good as the original Chinese text (I am told).

(btw: It will be very hard to follow the TV-series if you haven't read the book!)

Ecrit par: ah_thomas Jeudi 30 Avril 2009 14h40
That's why we needed the film, Pieter! I have not read the novel, nor watch the Tv series, but understood the film unedent.gif

© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)